Stephen Donaldson’s “The Real Story” is a compact yet intense novella set in a future where humanity traverses the stars using “gap drives.” In this future, brain implants are heavily regulated, and a private entity, the United Mining Company, serves as the law enforcement across known space. Ensign Morn Hyland, stationed on a police vessel with her family, dedicates her life to pursuing space pirates and smugglers who exploit the vulnerable.
The story takes a strange turn when Morn becomes associated with a notorious pirate. Observers at a space station bar speculate about Morn’s motives: why would a capable officer consort with such a figure? Rumors swirl around Morn’s alleged involvement with Captain Nick Succorso, suggesting a plot to frame Angus and escape together. However, the truth is far more complex.
As a prelude to a four-part series, “The Real Story” presents a straightforward narrative centered on the rivalry between space pirates Angus Thermopyle and Nick Succorso, and UMCP Ensign Morn Hyland. Told from Angus’s perspective, the story paints him as a deeply flawed character. His brutal actions towards Morn have sparked controversy, with some critics labeling them misogynistic. However, Donaldson’s intention appears to be to create a dark and unsettling atmosphere.
While “The Real Story” may feel incomplete as a standalone novel due to its brevity and limited character development, two key points are crucial to consider:
1. It was originally conceived as a novella, not the beginning of a series. Consequently, it lacks common series elements such as foreshadowing or hooks for future installments. Donaldson initially kept it unpublished, and it only gains its full context when viewed as part of the larger series. Understanding this mitigates some of its perceived shortcomings.
2. Despite the above, it undeniably serves as the first book in the series. The series itself improves dramatically from the second book onward. Accepting that the best parts are yet to come makes the flaws of “The Real Story” more bearable.
While acknowledging its weaknesses, it’s important not to let lukewarm reviews deter potential readers. “The Real Story” is not inherently bad, simply incomplete. However, be warned: it is a grim and brutal story. Furthermore, Donaldson prioritizes character-driven narratives over hard science, so those seeking detailed technology may be disappointed.